The Royal Commission on Antisemitism and Social Cohesion has recently been the subject of scrutiny regarding its hearings, particularly concerning the involvement of pro-Palestinian organizations. Commissioner Virginia Bell clarified that these groups did not “hijack” the inquiry, despite claims to the contrary from some within the Jewish community.
During the session, David Ossip, the president of the Jewish Board of Deputies, faced questioning from counsel representing the Australia Palestine Advocacy Network (APAN) and the Palestine Action Group (PAG). This inquiry was initiated to assess how the Jewish community perceived a protest organized by PAG, which took place on October 9, 2023, marching from the Town Hall to the Sydney Opera House.
APAN’s counsel, Ragni Mathur SC, challenged Mr. Ossip on his remarks regarding the protest’s timing, particularly in light of the violence occurring in Israel. Mathur prompted Ossip to acknowledge that Palestinian Australians were also experiencing significant fear regarding the situation in occupied territories. In response, Ossip emphasized the need for kindness and understanding among all Australian citizens, but he also expressed that organizing the rally during a period of violence against Israeli citizens reflected a lack of sensitivity.
The dialogue included discussions on the timeline of military actions taken by Israel following the Hamas attack on October 7, 2023. When questioned about the Palestinian death toll prior to that date, Mr. Ossip refrained from commenting.
Commissioner Bell addressed allegations made by a notable figure in the Jewish community, who suggested that the pro-Palestinian counsel was attempting to take control of the royal commission for sensational purposes. Although the commissioner did not disclose the individual’s name, reports indicated that Alex Ryvchin, from the Executive Council of Australian Jewry, was behind these statements.
Commissioner Bell defended Mathur’s participation, stating that her role was essential for the fair representation of interests affected by the proceedings, especially given the criticisms directed at her clients. She reiterated that procedural fairness necessitated Mathur’s questioning, which was specifically permitted to address a particular statement made by Ossip regarding Israel’s actions.
Moreover, Commissioner Bell condemned any Islamophobic attacks directed at Mathur, asserting that such behavior is unacceptable, just as antisemitic attacks are toward Jewish individuals giving evidence. Bell emphasized that targeting counsel with hateful rhetoric undermines the advocacy efforts they represent.
The commission is set to further investigate the roots of antisemitism in Australia, considering various forms of extremism, including religious and far-right ideologies. Counsel assisting Richard Lancaster SC indicated that upcoming hearings will feature both expert witnesses and individuals with personal experiences, including former extremists who have renounced their past beliefs. These sessions are anticipated to continue until August 14.
