Google has been penalized with a fine exceeding €400 million (£345 million) due to how it managed users’ location data. This decision follows allegations that the tech company misled users into consenting to be continuously monitored via their mobile devices.
The fine, enacted by Ireland’s Data Protection Commission (DPC), stems from complaints made by various European consumer groups, which asserted that Google was tracking users’ movements without adequate transparency.
While location-based advertisements are common, particularly for travelers, seven European consumer organizations raised concerns regarding the potential invasion of privacy associated with excessive use of location information.
The inquiry by the DPC was initiated in response to findings from the Norwegian consumer agency in 2018, which indicated that location data could divulge sensitive personal information, including religious affiliations (through visits to places of worship), political beliefs (such as attendance at protests), health issues (like hospital visits), and sexual orientation (based on frequented venues).
Launched six years ago, the DPC’s investigation aimed to determine whether Google had a legitimate legal justification for its location data practices.
The DPC concluded that many users might not have been aware that their location data was being utilized to tailor advertisements or gather insights about their health and preferences.
Graham Doyle, a deputy commissioner at the DPC, noted, “Location data, a form of personal information acquired through tracking, can reveal an individual’s whereabouts either independently or when combined with other data.” He added, “While location data can enhance online services, it can also disclose a considerable amount of private information.”
In reaction to the DPC’s decision, a Google representative stated, “This case revolves around past policies that have since been revised. Since 2019, we have significantly improved our practices and introduced comprehensive tools that facilitate the management of location data.”
The European Consumer Organisation (BEUC) based its complaint on research conducted by the Forbrukerrådet, the Norwegian consumer agency, which argued that Google employed “various tactics” to ensure that location history and web activity remained enabled.
Finn Myrstad, director of digital policy at the Norwegian Consumer Council, remarked, “This marks a significant step in our ongoing efforts to safeguard online rights. Individuals must be able to comprehend what they are consenting to, without being deceived or coerced into decisions they would not normally make.”
BEUC described geolocation data as “one of the most intrusive forms of consumer surveillance.”
Agustín Reyna, the general director of BEUC, expressed approval of the ruling but criticized the lengthy duration it took to arrive at this conclusion, stating, “The time taken to reach this decision is disproportionate to the severity of the violation, as delayed enforcement can be just as damaging as no enforcement at all.”
The DPC’s investigation focused on “web and app activity,” “location history,” and “location accuracy” from May 25, 2018, to February 4, 2020.
With the imposition of a €403 million fine, the DPC has mandated that Google align its practices with the EU’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) within six months.
This penalty ranks as the fourth-largest imposed by the Irish regulator, which oversees all major U.S. tech firms with European headquarters in Ireland. Previous fines include €1.2 billion for Meta, €530 million for TikTok, and €405 million for Instagram (also owned by Meta).
Doyle emphasized, “The GDPR ensures a high level of personal data protection across the EEA and mandates that the processing of personal information must be conducted lawfully, fairly, and transparently. Due to Google’s shortcomings, individuals may have been unaware that their location data was being used to influence them with targeted ads or infer their interests, resulting in a loss of control over their personal information.”
Additionally, there are three ongoing large-scale statutory inquiries involving Google, all of which are in advanced stages.


















