The Madras High Court has rejected a husband’s appeal against the refusal of his divorce petition, ruling that the presence of another person in the couple’s home, without dependable proof of adultery, is not enough to grant a divorce.
A bench comprising Justices G R Swaminathan and M D Sumathi upheld the family court’s decision to dismiss the husband’s petition and grant his wife’s request for restitution of conjugal rights. The ruling was issued on October 16.
The couple married in 2018 and lived at the husband’s family home. After their relationship deteriorated, the husband filed for divorce in 2019 under the Hindu Marriage Act, alleging adultery and cruelty.
He claimed that his wife had an illicit relationship with a man he identified as her stepfather. He also alleged that she neglected household duties and refused to consummate the marriage, causing him mental distress.
The wife denied the accusations and alleged that her husband was involved with his paternal uncle’s wife. She further claimed that he mistreated her and sought additional jewellery and money from her family. In a separate petition, she asked the court to direct the couple to resume living together.
The family court dismissed the husband’s divorce case and allowed the wife’s petition. The husband then appealed to the High Court.
In reviewing the adultery claim, the High Court noted that it was based on the alleged presence of the wife’s stepfather at the matrimonial home. The family court had taken account of the other people living there, while a witness had not given satisfactory direct evidence of the alleged incident.
The bench said allegations about the wife’s family background or the identity of her father could not, on their own, prove an illicit relationship. It added that any alleged concealment of family details and an accusation of adultery were separate issues that had to be assessed on the evidence relevant to each.
The judges also rejected the cruelty claim. They observed that routine disagreements, occasional disputes and broad complaints about household duties do not automatically amount to matrimonial cruelty.
The husband had said his wife refused to cook or serve him, failed to meet household responsibilities and often spoke on the telephone. The bench found these claims either lacked sufficient detail or were not supported by reliable evidence. It said cruelty could not be inferred simply because the spouses had made competing accusations; the circumstances and evidentiary basis of each claim had to be examined.
The High Court therefore dismissed the appeal and left the family court’s order in place.



















