A dispute over the relocation of centuries-old Jain idols from the Shri Rajpur Jain Shwetamber Murtipujak Chitamani Parshwanath Bhagwan Derasar in Gomtipur to Shilaj is before the Gujarat High Court. Five devotees allege that the trust’s trustees moved the idols without notifying the community or obtaining approval from the Charity Commissioner. They say the idols were removed during the night of February 10–11, 2025.
The petition claims the trustees acted “in conspiracy with some other persons and for their own selfish reasons”, removing the idols from the Jinalaya for installation at Shilaj.
Filed by advocate Utkarsh Dave, the petition challenges the Charity Commissioner’s August 21, 2026, decision to reject the devotees’ request for the idols to be returned. The petitioners dispute the trustees’ power to move idols they say are 400 to 500 years old. They argue that relocating them was an administrative decision requiring scrutiny, rather than a matter of religious practice. The High Court is scheduled to hear the case on December 3.
The devotees, led by Vinod Sakalchand Shah, say the trust’s registered objectives do not authorise trustees to transfer the idols from their original temple. Registered on January 2, 1953, the trust’s stated purposes include conducting seva-puja and other rituals, managing temple property, and carrying out construction and repairs.
The petition says the disagreement dates back to 2006, when devotees asked the Charity Commissioner to prevent a proposed relocation. That application was disposed of on December 28, 2006, after the trustees said they had not passed a resolution to move the idols.
According to the filing, eight trustees were added to the existing six in November and December 2022. The petitioners allege that all eight newcomers were builders operating in Shilaj.
On February 1, 2025, the trustees passed a resolution to move the idols to land in Shilaj donated to the trust by Aryan Build Projects LLP. The petition says the trustees argued that few Jain devotees visited the Gomtipur temple and that the idols should be moved to a more developed area of Ahmedabad, such as Shilaj. The trust accepted a donation of about 1,700 square yards for a new Derasar and complex.
The devotees say they applied under the Gujarat Public Trusts Act, 1950, on February 18, 2025, seeking an order to return the idols. The Charity Commissioner directed the parties to maintain the status quo that day. A separate public interest litigation was dismissed by the High Court on May 6, 2025.
In challenging the Charity Commissioner’s decision, the petitioners argue that the authority failed to distinguish religious practice from the administration of religious institutions. They also contest its reliance on earlier proceedings and a 1976 Bombay High Court ruling on judicial restraint in religious matters.
The petition seeks to overturn the Charity Commissioner’s order and the trustees’ February 1, 2025, resolution. It also asks that the idols, jewellery and decorative items be returned to the Gomtipur temple at the trustees’ expense, that alleged damage to the premises be repaired, and that the idols not be installed in Shilaj or any remaining idols moved while the case is pending.


















