, , , , , , , ,

Martha Stewart’s Halloween Costume Backlash Raises a Question: Why Do Celebrities Take the Risk? | Coco Khan

Sri Lanka Digital Media Network

Submit Your Press Release

Get your company news, announcements, launches, appointments and events in front of a wider audience.

NewsDive Financial Chronicle Ceylon Independent Daily FC
Submit Your Press Release →
Publish Across Our Network

Optimism can feel like hard work. I try to treat it as a skill that needs regular practice, using hopeful counterarguments to push back against the grim news. When reports warn that global temperatures may pass the 2C mark, I remind myself that solutions exist. When authoritarian movements gain ground, I think about how people have resisted them before.

This week, however, that exercise became harder after US lifestyle celebrity Martha Stewart shared a Halloween photo of herself dressed as a homeless person. Her face was streaked with dirt, and she held a sign that read, “I AM HUNGRY HELP ME!!”

Perhaps there is a more cheerful explanation: Stewart is preparing to reinvent herself as a provocative, anti-comedy performer called Martha Stewart Lee. Her new show, Laundered, could earn glowing reviews: “After years of immaculate table settings, Martha Stewart offers something genuinely uncomfortable: herself.” Five stars.

Long before social media influencers made a career out of looking like a living inspiration board, Stewart had established herself as a leading authority on domestic life in the United States. Now 85, she built a business spanning books, magazines, television and home products. Her company went public in 1999, making her a billionaire. In 2004, she was found guilty of conspiracy, obstructing an agency proceeding and lying to federal investigators. She spent five months in prison.

Reaction to the costume was swift. “What in the ‘let them eat cake’ is this?” one social media user asked. Stewart soon removed the post, but not before screenshots spread. The incident placed her among celebrities remembered for deeply insensitive costumes: Bill Maher once dressed as the recently deceased conservationist Steve Irwin, while Chloë Sevigny appeared as the body of Diana, Princess of Wales. Other examples include the long history of celebrities wearing blackface and occasions when public figures have treated genocide or Indigenous cultures as costume material, including Prince Harry’s Nazi uniform.

Stewart’s explanation followed a familiar pattern: she said she was “distressed” that people had taken offence, despite the plainly offensive image. She claimed the costume was intended to draw attention to homelessness. Yet the post also promoted her QVC candles, with the message, “My QVC candles are perfect for Halloween!!!”

Taking that explanation at face value, perhaps the image was meant as a deliberate provocation—a jarring reminder of hardship appearing alongside an invitation to shop for candles. It is possible. But the episode also offers a glimpse of how people with wealth and influence may reduce others’ suffering to an outfit, a stunt or a joke.

Whatever one thinks of “Martha Stewart Lee,” the performance has certainly prompted discussion.

More broadly, why do these episodes keep occurring? Public figures often depend on popular approval, and many have teams and social media channels that could help them anticipate a backlash. Some deliberately court controversy, but Stewart does not seem an obvious example, even though she has previously turned scandal into renewed success after prison. If these costumes were simply calculated publicity, it is hard to explain why their wearers so often issue apologies afterwards.

Perhaps people around the wealthy hesitate to challenge them. Someone might have warned a celebrity that dressing as a Hindu goddess could be seen as disrespectful rather than daring. Online platforms may also encourage increasingly shocking content. But the deeper problem may be the isolation that comes with great wealth: a sheltered existence among people of similar status can weaken one’s understanding of ordinary standards of respect. Even Stewart’s time in prison—where she may have encountered women who had experienced homelessness—did not prevent her from using poverty as a costume.

There is, at least, one reason to feel encouraged. The controversy brought renewed attention to homelessness, with reports noting that more than 700,000 people in the United States are without homes. At a time when rising living costs are putting pressure on many households, the public response also made clear that poverty is not a punchline. That is one small exercise for anyone trying to strengthen their optimism.

Coco Khan is a freelance writer and co-host of the politics podcast Pod Save the UK.

Readers who wish to respond to the issues raised may submit a letter of up to 300 words by email for consideration in the publication’s letters section.


AI Search


NewsDive – News Search

NewsDive

Dive deep into the news that matter

🌍 Detecting your location…

Select a Newspaper

Breaking News Latest Business Economy Political Sports Entertainment US-Iran War International

Search Results

Top Categories

Latest News


Sri Lanka


Australia


India


United Kingdom


USA


Sports